Catalog Marketing Surge Is Fueled by Digital's Tracking Crackdown and Costs

AccuList® has a long list of consumer catalog clients, and we've noted renewed interest in traditional print catalogs, especially among direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands. Why? One reason is Apple's crackdown on the ability of consumer data platforms, such as Google and Meta's Facebook, to track and target consumers, per a recent Ad Age report. For example, Insider Intelligence data shows DTC brands cut ad budgets for Facebook and Instagram by almost 8% between January 2021 and January 2022, and increased offline marketing from 12% to 15% of spending. 

Rising acquisition costs for digital channels are another factor driving expanded catalog budgets. A SeQuel Response survey found 44% of  DTC brands boosted direct mail spending in 2022, with more than half blaming the rising customer acquisition costs of digital channels. 

Catalogs also are seen as better retention tools. Ad Age cites menswear brand Todd Snyder's report that its catalog buyers tend to purchase from the brand for longer periods and to purchase more items, and that its annual holiday catalog is used to "bring back lapsed customers." 

Finally, unlike easily ignored digital advertising, catalogs are more likely to capture and keep consumer attention. Kara O'Brien, head of offline marketing at furniture and home goods retailer Wayfair, explained to Ad Age that their seasonal catalog gives "that extra real estate...to tell richer product stories and invite customers into all that Wayfair has to offer. And it has staying power—a tangible print piece is something consumers can keep, bookmark, revisit and even share with family and friends." 

If you're thinking of joining the trend by adding or expanding catalogs in your marketing mix, AccuList can help. See https://www.acculist.com/consumer-catalogs/

Insert Media Offer Cost-Effective Audience Reach

Insert media, direct mail's less glamorous relative, is also a proven way to reach new customers, and AccuList helps clients place offers in a range of printed insert options such as package inserts; publication "blow-in," "bind-in" and onsert programs; postcard decks; statement stuffers; and cooperative mailing programs. In the digital space, there also are webserts to qualified online buyers. Insert media programs may seem old-fashioned, but younger recipients actually embrace them. For example, Quad/Graphics research has found that 49% of millennials said they ignored Internet ads, and 48% said they ignored e-mail, but only 25% ignored retail inserts! Or on the flip side, 73% said they paid attention to retail inserts vs. 48% who paid attention to mobile text. Plus, insert media have a number of virtues that make them attractive to direct marketers: They leverage co-branding since offers "ride along" with material from an already trusted source; they avoid postage costs and save on printing expenses; and they offer a targeted audience. In choosing insert media, the first step is to consider your desired target audience and its match with the demographics and purchase history/interests of the host program. Next, as with any direct marketing effort, test and re-test, making sure there is a large enough universe for future rollout. You can test for both creative/offer and audience category, but if finding the right audience and host program is the goal and the budget is limited, it's probably better to test four different audience groups/programs rather than four creatives to the same audience/program. Of course, once a control is developed for rollout, continue to test against it. And be wary of potential audience duplication: Using different programs with the same owner, a package insert and a statement insert for example, might reach the same recipients at different times. Insert media today are usually part of an omnichannel strategy. That means inserts should provide more than one response option: business reply card, 800 number, URL, and mobile QR code. And it means tracking and analyzing results across channels. So make sure to provide a unique code on pieces to track response by program, offer, audience category, insert month/timing. etc. And if you use a mobile QR code, with links to an offer/purchase landing page or a reply/request page, be sure online pages are mobile-optimized! Because inserts are competing for attention with other offers, your creative needs to stand out in design and messaging, with a clear call to action. Plus, in scheduling insert media, remember that you are at the mercy of the host program's timings and availability. Plan with seasonality in mind and build in adequate lead times. For more, see https://www.acculist.com/insert-media-offer-cost-effective-marketing-options/